The Parent's Guide to Self-Discipline (Why Your Consistency Matters More Than Rules)

When my father-in-law asked my husband, "Do you ever say no to this child?" I knew we were onto something. Here's what we learned about the discipline that actually matters in parenting.

We've all been there. Your toddler throws a tantrum in Target, and you hear yourself saying, "I'm counting to three! One... two... two and a half... two and three-quarters... are you coming?" Sound familiar?

What if I told you that the secret to effective child discipline isn't about disciplining your kids at all? It's about disciplining yourself as a parent.

Why Most Parent Discipline Strategies Fail

Here's the uncomfortable truth: most of us are terrible at following through. We make threats we don't keep, set boundaries we don't enforce, and wonder why our kids don't take us seriously.

My husband figured this out early in our parenting journey. He realized something crucial: if he knew he was going to say yes eventually, he would never say no in the first place.

This led him to say as few "nos" as possible to our young son. But here's the game-changer - when he did say no, it was absolutely unbreakable.

The Foundation of Consistent Parenting: Self-Discipline

Rule #1: Think Before You Speak

Don't say no as a knee-jerk reaction. Before you respond to any request, ask yourself: "Is this really something that requires a no?"

Here's why this matters: if you're only going to say a minimal number of nos, every single one needs to have a real explanation behind it. You can't just say no because you can, or because it's easier, or because that's what popped out first.

If you're going to cave later anyway, don't start with no. This simple shift meant we avoided countless power struggles and maintained our credibility with our kids.

Rule #2: United Front, Always

As a couple, we established one non-negotiable rule: if one of us said no, and the other was aware of it, you'd never say yes until you could align with your partner.

The other crucial piece? Whenever we suspected a question had already been asked of the other parent, we'd say, "Well, what did your mom/dad already say?" This prevented the classic kid strategy of shopping around for the answer they wanted.

Rule #3: Follow Through, No Matter What

This was the hardest part for me. I was more in the "I'm kinda gonna count to 3" realm, but I learned to actually follow through.

I would count: "1, 2, 3," and then turn and go if that's what I said I would do. I'll never forget how I would start walking toward the corner, thinking, "Oh my god, what am I going to do when I reach the corner? Because I'm not going to turn back and pick up the child - that's breaking my own discipline as a parent."

Here's what happened: I never reached that corner. The child always caught up to me before that happened.

When Counting to Three Actually Works

Most parenting experts will tell you that counting to three doesn't work. They're right - when parents use it inconsistently. But here's what worked for my family:

The language that developed between me and my sons was this: me saying "I'm counting to 3" actually meant "guys, I mean business." Eventually, it evolved to "I'm counting to 3, and I'm going."

We used it for all kinds of situations:

• "Listen, I asked you to put your stuff away. Okay, I'm getting upset. What's going on here? I'm gonna count to 3."

• Eventually, as they grew older, I didn't even get to 1. I'd say, "I'm gonna count to 3," and they'd think, "Oh, mom means business," and they'd do it.

The Evolution of Disciplined Parenting

Being aware of this discipline in our parenting grew over time. At the beginning, it was simply: don't say no if you don't have to, because if you're going to say no and then switch to yes, you're breaking your own word.

But over time, we became more disciplined as parents - staying consistent, following through. And because we had that baseline established, we also started giving ourselves more leeway.

We could say, "Okay, today something is special, so a rule might be broken. It's a holiday, we just had a really great success," whatever it was. Knowing that baseline was already solid, and we had an open channel of communication, allowed us to veer off the rules and still stay disciplined.

What This Looks Like in Practice

For Toddlers and Preschoolers

• Think before you respond to requests

• Make your "no" mean something by using it sparingly

• Follow through immediately when you set a boundary

• Present a united front with your partner

For School-Age Kids

As your children start moving from the toddler phase into school, you start explaining more. But here's the key: in order to be ready for that phase, you always have to know why you're saying no.

This goes back to avoiding the knee-jerk reaction. Really think about it - don't say no just because you can. Don't default to "because I said so."

I actually think that in my whole 20-something years of being a parent, I said "because I said so" once. And it was: "Listen, kids, there IS an explanation, but I'm too tired to give it. So today, you're gonna do this because I said so."

That honesty - acknowledging there was a reason but being transparent about my limitations in that moment - maintained the trust while still getting cooperation.

The Long-Term Impact of Parental Self-Discipline

This approach was actually pretty easy to maintain once we established it. We set up a system that worked very early on, and it created predictability for everyone in the family.

The best part? As our children grew, they understood that when we meant business, we really meant it. But they also learned that we were thoughtful about our decisions and wouldn't make arbitrary rules just because we could.

Starting Your Own Disciplined Parenting Journey

If you're ready to try this approach, here's where to start:

1. Audit your current patterns: How often do you make threats you don't follow through on?

2. Align with your partner: Have a conversation about presenting a united front

3. Practice the pause: Before saying no, ask yourself if this really requires a no

4. Commit to follow-through: Decide that your word will mean something

5. Start small: Pick one area where you'll be absolutely consistent

Remember, this isn't about being harsh or inflexible with your kids. It's about being trustworthy, predictable, and disciplined in your own responses. When children know what to expect from their parents, they feel more secure - and they're more likely to respect the boundaries you do set.

The Bottom Line

The real secret to effective discipline isn't finding the perfect consequence or the right parenting technique. It's developing the self-discipline to be consistent, thoughtful, and reliable in your responses to your children.

Your kids are watching everything you do. They're learning whether your words have weight, whether they can trust you to mean what you say, and whether you respect your own rules enough to enforce them.

What they learn from watching you will shape how they approach boundaries, commitments, and relationships for the rest of their lives. That's a responsibility worth taking seriously - and it starts with disciplining yourself first.

What's worked for your family when it comes to consistent discipline? Share your experiences in the comments below.

---

Related Posts:

• Back to: Creating Healthy Family Dynamics
• Family Game Time Has Its Own Power
• Using Consequences For Long Lasting Results

How The Brain Sabotages Good Parenting (The White Rabbit Effect)

Have you ever told your child "don't touch that" only to watch them immediately reach for it? There's actually a psychological reason this happens - and once you understand it, you'll never parent the same way again.

The White Rabbit Mind Trap Every Parent Falls Into

Here's a quick experiment: Don't think of white rabbits.

Right now, don't picture fluffy white rabbits hopping around. Don't imagine their twitching noses or soft ears. Whatever you do, don't think about white rabbits.

What happened? If you're like most people, the first thing that popped into your head was... white rabbits. Maybe you thought about why I'm asking you not to think about them, or wondered how you're supposed to not think about white rabbits. Either way, those white rabbits dominated your thoughts until you eventually realized the only way to stop thinking about them was to force yourself to think about something else entirely - like carrots.

And that takes a lot of mental effort.

This is exactly what happens when we tell our kids "don't do that."

Why the Human Brain Can't Handle "Don't"

The human brain is unequipped to work in a void. When we say "don't do something," we're creating a mental void - a space where no clear instruction exists.

As adults, we've developed coping mechanisms to handle this discomfort. We can mentally redirect ourselves, reason through alternatives, or push through the awkward mental gymnastics. It still makes us uncomfortable, but we can manage it.

Our kids don't have any way to handle this void yet.

Here's what happens in a child's brain when you tell them "don't touch that lamp": The child understans the directive and their brain start complying. Since the direction is "don't" it is trying to not do. The "don't" therefore creates an empty space where clear direction should be. But nature abhors a vacuum, and the mind abhors a void. So the "touch that lamp" part grows bigger and bigger to fill up that empty space.

Which means when you tell your child don't do something, you're actually pushing them into compulsively doing it - because in that moment, touching the lamp becomes the only concrete instruction existing in their mind.

Just to illustrate the point - I wanted to create an image for this section about "don't touch the lamp". Without speech bubbles I couldn't find a way. That's the void.

The Void Effect: Why Kids Seem to "Defy" Us on Purpose

This void effect explains why our kids seem to deliberately do the exact opposite of what we ask. It's not defiance - it's their brain desperately trying to fill an impossible mental space.

When there's no positive instruction to focus on, the forbidden action becomes the only clear, concrete thing in their awareness. Of course they're going to do it - it's literally the only direction their brain has received.

For kids, whose impulse control is still developing, this void effect is even more powerful than the white rabbit phenomenon we experience as adults. They don't have the mental tools to redirect themselves out of that empty space, so the forbidden behavior becomes magnified and almost irresistible.

Breaking My Own Negative Command Habit

I discovered this void explanation when our firstborn was very young - right at the beginning of what looked like "perceived defiance." Because we were trying not to say no as much as possible, we didn't have many white rabbits running around our house initially.

But I had a vocabulary problem I didn't know existed.

I grew up in a household with negative language patterns. Even when consciously trying to avoid "don't" commands, my automatic response was still to say "Stop!" or "No!" or "Don't do that!"

Then my conscious mind would immediately pop up and think, "Wait - negative space!" And I would quickly follow up with positive direction: "Don't touch that - touch this instead" or "Don't run - please walk."

It was like constantly catching up to myself and correcting the mistake. But fixing my "don't" with an immediate "do" worked like magic. It was phenomenally effective.

What I realized is that I didn't find any mental effort in thinking about what to say as a positive alternative - because my brain, just like other people's brains, just like my kids' brains, works harder in the negative space, in the void. Once I moved out of that void, I always knew what I wanted them to do within a fraction of a second.

"Don't scribble on the wall" was my knee-jerk response, but immediately I'd think, "Well, you scribble on paper in my household, right? Here's a piece of paper - scribble on that." It's also perfectly okay to explain the rule: "We like our walls white, so we scribble on paper."

The positive alternatives came naturally and effortlessly once I got out of that uncomfortable void space. The struggle was only in that negative space.

You don't have to strive to be perfect with your language. You just have to make sure your child isn't left sitting in that negative void space. Even if the negative command slips out first, quickly filling that void with clear, positive direction solves the problem beautifully.

What to Say Instead of "Don't"

The solution isn't becoming a permissive parent who never sets boundaries. It's redirecting your child's brain toward what you DO want them to do, rather than what you DON'T want.

Replace "Don't" With Clear, Positive Direction

Instead of giving their brain something to suppress (and inevitably focus on), give it something specific to do:

• Instead of: "Don't run in the house"
  
  

• Try: "Please walk inside" or "Use your walking feet"
  
  

• Instead of: "Don't touch that"
  
  

• Try: "Keep your hands in your pockets" or "Touch this instead"
  
  

• Instead of: "Don't yell"
  
  

• Try: "Use your quiet voice" or "Whisper like this"
  
  

Give Their Brain a Positive Target

When you rephrase requests positively, you're giving your child's brain a clear target to aim for rather than something to avoid.

Understanding Positive vs. Negative Commands

I'm not saying there are no boundaries or rules - quite the opposite. The thing is the wording itself and using the correct way to communicate with our brains.

"Stop" is actually a positive command. It tells you what to do - literally stop what you're doing right now.

"Don't touch the stove" is a negative command that creates a void. Even in a safety situation, you've just told them to touch the stove by making that the only concrete instruction in their mind.

"The stove is hot. Let's touch it gently to see how it feels and understand why it's probably best to touch something else" is better. You're giving them information and positive direction rather than creating that dangerous void.

The key is being intentional about using language that works with how brains actually process information, especially in moments when you need immediate compliance for safety reasons.

The Long-Term Impact on Family Dynamics

When you set up your child to be disobedient by working against their brain, you're also setting up the entire relationship on a trajectory that's negative.

If this becomes the main way things go in your house, if that trajectory keeps getting momentum and you don't break this cycle, it will harbor misunderstandings and distrust, and sap energy from your relationship.

The important thing is that it's easy to break the cycle. And as soon as you do - whether your kid is just starting to follow instructions or is already a teenager - once you understand that you set up the cycle, you can break it quite easily.

But here's the beautiful part: if you go on the new trajectory of giving positive instructions that make sense, that come from a place of logic and not just tyranny, you're opening up communication channels. You're letting your child show you their capabilities.

When I stopped trapping my kids' brains in white rabbit cycles, they became more cooperative overall. They weren't constantly fighting against negative commands, and I wasn't constantly frustrated by their apparent "defiance."

Making the Switch: Your Action Plan

If you're ready to break the white rabbit cycle in your home, here's how to start:

1. Catch yourself: For one day, just notice how often you say "don't," "stop," or "no"

2. Pause before speaking: Take a breath and ask "what do I want them to do instead?"

3. Rephrase one command at a time: Don't try to change everything at once

4. Be patient with yourself: Like any new habit, this takes practice

The Bottom Line: Give Their Brains Something Better to Focus On

The white rabbit experiment teaches us something profound about how our minds work - and our kids' developing brains are no different. When we constantly tell them what NOT to do, we're accidentally training their attention on exactly the behaviors we want to eliminate.

Instead of trying to suppress unwanted behaviors, give your kids' brains something better to focus on. Just like thinking about carrots instead of white rabbits, positive redirection gives them a clear target to aim for.

It's not about being a pushover parent or never setting boundaries. It's about working with your child's brain instead of against it.

What's one "don't" command you find yourself using repeatedly with your kids? Try rephrasing it as a positive direction and share how it goes in the comments!

---

Related Posts:

• Back to: Creating Healthy Family Dynamics
• The Self Discipline Parents Need
• Using Consequences For Long Lasting Results

The Power of Playing Together: Building Connection Through Fun

Reading through my old parenting posts, I realized something that made me cringe. It looks like we were always disciplining our kids, always getting them in line, always saying no.

But that's not the whole story.

The truth is, we had a ton of fun as parents. Our family dynamic was incredibly positive and playful. We genuinely enjoyed each other's company - movie nights, adventures, international travel, skiing, and even a 6-week Normandy trip crammed in a camper van. Just the four of us in a tin can on wheels.

The kids would tell you it was the best time ever.

Why Family Game Time Gets Overlooked

Parenting blogs (including mine) spend so much time discussing challenges and solutions that we forget the good stuff. The fun stuff. The moments when everyone's laughing so hard they can't breathe.

But playing together as a family? That's where the magic really happens.

Our Family Game Night Philosophy: Throw Out the Box Rules

We became a board game family early on, and here's what worked: we completely ignored most "rules" about how games should be played.

Creating Our Own House Rules

Take Monopoly. We played it constantly, but over years, we adjusted it to work better for our family. Some cards were repurposed, and we completely changed tax calculations.

This wasn't unique to Monopoly. If we played a game and decided a rule was too harsh, wasn't fun, or seemed stupid, we changed it. This became our "house version" of whatever we were playing.

Later, we bought Kiyosaki's Cash Flow game. We found it incredibly educational and discussed it extensively during and after playing. It genuinely influenced how we see money and shaped how our kids think about financial freedom.

Bending More Than Just Game Rules

Game time was also a chance to bend regular house rules. Disrespect to parents wasn't condoned during regular family life. But when playing games, we all stepped away from traditional parent-child roles.

You could be snide. You could be cheeky with your parents because you were just playing a game. The usual formalities relaxed, and everyone could engage as more equal players rather than family hierarchy.

Box rules were just starting points - for games and for family dynamics during play.

Age Recommendations Are Just Suggestions

Those ages on the box? Gentle recommendations. If the box said ages 5-10 and my 3-year-old wanted to play with his older brother, we let him. If he wanted to play differently than what was written, that was sometimes okay.

The key: if his playing style disrupted the rest of us actually playing, we wouldn't play with him in that moment. But we wouldn't punish him or stop him from playing his own version either.

The "He Left Them at Home" Moment

I have to share this story because it perfectly captures why playing together creates incredible family memories.

My husband and youngest son were playing Guess Who? Each picked their mystery person and started the usual questioning. Eventually, my husband narrows it down and says confidently, "Okay, your person is John."

But remember - little son couldn't read yet. Dad had to show him which face was John.

"No, it's not John. It's Michael," my son says, pointing to a completely different face.

My husband looks at the Michael card and says, "But son, Michael doesn't have glasses. You said your person has glasses."

Without missing a beat, my 4-year-old looks him straight in the eye and says, "Yes, he does. He left them at home."

The logic was flawless. The creativity was incredible. We still laugh about it years later.

What Playing Together Actually Teaches Kids

Beyond obvious family bonding benefits, engaging in shared tasks allows family members to connect and understand each other on deeper levels, reinforcing trust, appreciation, and affection.

Creativity trumps rigid rule-following. When kids feel safe to bend rules creatively (like glasses left at home), they're learning to think outside the box and find multiple solutions to problems.

Flexible thinking creates better memories than perfect compliance. Sure, we could have insisted on playing Guess Who? "correctly." But then we would have missed some of the most creative thinking I've ever witnessed.

Family fun doesn't need to follow a rulebook to be perfect. Some of our best family memories come from games that went completely off the rails. As long as the family is having fun and laughing together, it's perfect exactly as it is.

Games That Actually Worked for Our Family

Board Games with Staying Power

Monopoly was our constant companion. We created house rules - some cards did different things than originally intended, and we completely overhauled tax calculations.

Settlers of Catan solved our biggest family gaming problem: burnout. Usually, one of us would figure out a winning strategy, teach the others, and the game would become boring. But Settlers' design makes each round completely different, keeping our interest for years.

Guess Who? provided endless entertainment, especially when creative interpretations were allowed.

Card Games for Every Occasion

We built a travel survival kit around card games. Whist and Canasta became family staples. UNO was our go-to portable game, though we played with modified rules that worked better for our family dynamics.

Educational Games That Actually Taught Us

Kiyosaki's Cash Flow Game was incredibly educational. We discussed it extensively, and it genuinely influenced how we approach money and financial decisions. More importantly, it shaped how our kids think about financial freedom.

Other games we played extensively include Citadels and Avalon - both excellent for families who enjoy strategy and mystery.

The Game Burnout Problem (And How Settlers Solved It)

As a family, we had a major issue with game burnout. One of us would figure out a winning strategy, teach it to the others, and suddenly the game would become boring.

But Settlers of Catan has ingenious design that makes each round completely different. The board changes, resource distribution changes, and strategies that worked last time might not work this time. This maintained our interest for years - something that rarely happened with other games.

Making Time for Fun as a Family

Structure and discipline are important. I stand by everything I've written about consistency. But if that's all we're doing as parents, we're missing the joy.

Your family's identity shouldn't just be about rules and consequences. It should also be about laughter, creativity, and the kind of inside jokes that last for decades.

The Permission to Have Fun

If you're thinking "but we have so many other things to work on with our kids," I get it. There's always something needing fixing, addressing, or improving.

But here's what worked for my family: making time for pure fun gave us a foundation of connection that made all the other parenting stuff easier. When your kids genuinely enjoy spending time with you, they're more likely to listen when you need serious conversations.

The discipline and boundaries matter. But so does the laughter.

So tonight, maybe grab a deck of cards. Or dust off that board game sitting in the closet. Don't worry about playing it perfectly.

Just play.

What games have created the best memories in your family? Share your favorite family game moments in the comments - especially the times when things went hilariously off-script!

---

Related Posts:

• Back to: Creating Healthy Family Dynamics
• How the Brain Sabotages Good Parenting

Building Healthy Family Dynamics: The Real Foundation Of Happy Families

 Every family has its own unique rhythm, but beneath daily routines lie deeper patterns - the family dynamics that either bring you closer together or slowly pull you apart.

Most parents focus on managing behavior and teaching lessons. But here's what I've learned: the most important work we do isn't about controlling our kids' behavior. It's about creating family dynamics that bring out the best in everyone and help each family member thrive.

What Are Family Dynamics, Really?

Family dynamics are the invisible patterns governing how your family operates:

• Communication styles and decision-making processes

• How conflicts resolve (or don't) and trust builds

• How fun happens and individual needs balance with family needs

Most families develop these patterns accidentally, without considering whether they actually work.

The Four Pillars of Healthy Family Dynamics

Through trial and error, our family discovered four key elements that transformed how we related to each other. These aren't perfect rules - they're principles that help create family culture where everyone can flourish.

Pillar 1: Connection Over Control

The heart of healthy family dynamics is genuine relationship, not behavioral management. When families focus primarily on controlling behavior, they sacrifice the connections that make cooperation possible.

Children who feel genuinely enjoyed and understood by their parents naturally cooperate with family expectations. This doesn't mean being permissive - it means recognizing that your relationship with your child is the foundation everything else builds on.

Key insight: Kids who feel connected to their family want to contribute to family harmony. Kids who feel controlled often resist out of self-preservation.

Pillar 2: Working With Psychology, Not Against It

Understanding how minds actually work - both yours and your children's - changes everything. Most family conflict happens because we accidentally work against how brains naturally function.

When you align your parenting approach with how minds process information, cooperation increases and power struggles decrease dramatically. Your child's "defiance" is often just their brain responding predictably to confusing messages.

Pillar 3: Parental Integrity and Consistency

The most important discipline in your family is your own self-discipline as a parent. Children learn more from what we do than what we say. When parents are consistent, predictable, and reliable, it creates safety and trust.

This isn't about perfection - it's about being intentional. Think before you react, follow through on what you say, and maintain emotional regulation even when things get challenging.

Pillar 4: Natural Learning Over Artificial Consequences

The world is already full of natural feedback. Our job is helping kids learn from it, not piling on additional punishment. This builds internal motivation and genuine life skills.

This approach requires more wisdom and patience from parents, but creates children who make good choices because they understand how the world works, not just because they fear getting in trouble.

How These Pillars Work Together

These four elements reinforce each other. When you prioritize connection, maintaining emotional regulation becomes easier. When you understand psychology, natural consequences make more sense. When you're consistent, kids feel safer being authentic with you.

The result? Family dynamics that serve everyone, not just parents trying to maintain control.

What Healthy Family Dynamics Look Like

Families with healthy dynamics share common characteristics:

Daily interactions feel collaborative, not adversarial. Structure and expectations exist, balanced with flexibility and responsiveness to individual needs.

Conflicts get resolved rather than shut down. When disagreements happen, family members work through them without anyone feeling diminished.

Everyone's voice matters. Even young children have input into decisions affecting them, and parents consider different perspectives.

Fun and connection happen naturally. Families don't work hard to enjoy each other's company - it flows from built trust and affection.

Individual differences are celebrated, not tolerated. Each family member can be authentically themselves while contributing to family harmony.

Starting to Shift Your Family Dynamics

If your family's current patterns aren't serving everyone well, here's where to start:

Observe without judgment. Spend a week noticing your family's patterns. How do you handle conflicts? What brings out the best in each family member?

Focus on one element at a time. Don't try changing everything at once. Pick one pillar that resonates most and focus there for a few weeks.

Expect resistance (including your own). Changing established patterns feels uncomfortable for everyone, even when changes are positive.

Celebrate small wins. Notice when interactions go well, conflicts resolve peacefully, or someone tries a new approach. Positive momentum builds on itself.

The Long-Term Vision

I want your family to genuinely enjoy each other's company. I want your children to feel safe being themselves around you. I want family time to feel nourishing rather than draining.

Most of all, I want your family dynamics to be something you're proud of - not because they're perfect, but because they reflect your values and serve everyone in your family well.

---

Dive Deeper: Transform Your Family Dynamics

Ready to explore specific strategies? Each post tackles one crucial element:

The Power of Playing Together: Building Connection Through Fun - Discover how prioritizing fun creates the foundation for everything else.

How Your Brain Sabotages Good Parenting - Learn to communicate in ways that work with your child's brain.

The Parent's Guide to Self-Discipline - Build the consistency that helps children feel safe and secure.

Natural Consequences That Actually Teach - Help your children develop internal motivation and real-world wisdom.

---

What's one change you could make this week that would improve your family's dynamics? Share your experiences in the comments below.

How to Filter Parenting Advice Without Losing Your Mind (Trust Yourself First)

There's something that bothers me about most parenting books and advice. It's not that they're necessarily wrong—it's that they speak with exclamation marks when I prefer what I call "hesitation words."

You know what I mean. Those books that tell you exactly what to do, when to do it, and how your child will respond. The ones that make sweeping declarations about child development like they've discovered the secret formula for every family.

Here's the thing: everybody will have an opinion about how you should parent, and you can't make everybody happy all the time. You have to stay true to yourself and look inward to see what clicks, what works, what feels right.

The Problem with Parenting Advice Culture

I believe in those moments when you find an explanation and everything makes sense. Everything starts looking right, feeling right. That's where you go. But most parenting advice doesn't respect that process—it assumes one size fits all.

The biggest issue I have with books, TV shows, and self-appointed advisers is that they tend to speak with certainty where I believe we need more nuance. Even when I'm sharing strategies, I try not to decide for other people because I don't want anybody deciding for me.

Facts vs. Opinions: Learning the Difference

I state facts as facts. The gravitational force of Earth is 9.8 meters per second squared. If I've read that language develops in the human brain at a certain process, the fact that it's written in a book is a fact.

But here's what I can tell you from experience: not all kids will develop that way. It's helpful to know what the middle ground is, what the common denominator is. That's how I approach advice.

My Framework for Evaluating Advice

When I encounter parenting advice—whether from books, experts, or well-meaning relatives—I want them to respect me, my voice, my thoughts, my belief system, and the fact that I don't have to accept whatever they say 100%.

What I Look For:

1. Clear Assumptions
I want to understand what assumptions the advice is based on. What are the underlying beliefs? Do they make sense to me? Do they fit my family?

2. Logical Reasoning
It's not enough that the assumptions are alright. They have to actually lead to the conclusion. Don't beat around the bush—show me the logical path.

3. Room for Individual Differences
The best advice acknowledges that families are different and gives you permission to adapt rather than demanding strict adherence.

Permission to Sample

I totally give myself permission to sample books. Leaf through them, take a little bit here, a little bit there. If I only want to take parts away, that's just as good as reading the whole thing.

You are not obligated to implement every piece of advice you encounter. Sometimes the value is in understanding different perspectives, even if you don't adopt the specific strategies.

This approach isn't just for parenting advice. I once took "Rich Dad Poor Dad" from the library and couldn't get through it. I found it extremely repetitive without adding new information after about page 15. I know people rave about it and the ideas are solid, but I was done early on.

But here's what happened: my son, in his early teens, took the book and read it completely. He had no problem with the style. He was very interested and asked me to find a place where we could play Cash Flow—the board game Robert Kiyosaki created.

I found a location, we went and played, enjoyed it so much we found another location and played again. Eventually, we bought the game ourselves.

I was okay with not reading the book front to back, even though it's considered "good" with solid ideas. I didn't find it helpful personally. Why force myself? But I could still extract value from the concept and find a way to engage with the ideas that worked for our family.

Real Examples: When Advice Didn't Fit

The Baby Signs Experiment

When our firstborn was a few months old, I bought books to help navigate new parenthood. I was extremely excited about baby signs—a communication system you develop with your baby before they can talk.

Until I realized my kid was way too busy to spend time creating sign language with me. He was quite communicative, and we were very attentive. We understood enough of what he wanted that he didn't need much from us.

Both my kids were early developers. Life was running away from them, and they were catching up. We didn't have time for communication systems that felt unnecessary for our particular situation.

But here's the key: I enjoyed reading the book. I read it front to back, gave it a try, realized it didn't fit us, but I listened to what they said about being attentive. Then I gave myself permission to not be perfect and figured out that while sign language with children is really cute, it wasn't going to happen in our life.

The Sleep Training Reality Check

I got a book about child sleep from a pediatrician specializing in pediatric sleep issues. Main points: sleep schedules are critically important, babies need tons of sleep, don't let them get up to feed after they're big enough not to need it, and use the "5-minute system" to teach them to fall asleep alone.

With our first child: One night and done. Worked perfectly.

With our second child: We tried one night, two nights, three nights, five nights. It wasn't going to work. That kid was not going to do the 5-minute system.

We had to sit in his room and help him go to sleep night after night until he was ready to let it go. We developed a different system where I started sitting right next to him, then every night moved away bit by bit until I was in the doorway, then finally left him to fall asleep alone.

I later found out Super Nanny explained a similar method, but we came to it on our own because we paid attention to what our specific child needed.

The People Factor

When evaluating parenting advice, remember you're not alone in this process. There are other people involved—mainly your spouse and your children. Sometimes, there simply is no fit between the advice and your family's reality.

The advice might be sound, but it might not be right for your situation. That doesn't make you a failure—it makes you a thoughtful parent who pays attention to your family's unique needs.

Questions to Ask Before Following Advice

• Does this align with my family's values and lifestyle?
• What assumptions is this advice based on, and do they apply to my situation?
• Is there room for modification, or does it require strict adherence?
• How does my child typically respond to new routines or expectations?
• What does my parental instinct tell me about this approach?

Trust Your Instincts While Staying Open

You always have to be ready to re-challenge everything. Nothing should be set in stone unless it's proven to work for your family. The goal isn't to reject all advice—it's to develop critical thinking skills to evaluate what serves your family and what doesn't.

Your parenting journey is unique. The combination of your child's temperament, your family's circumstances, and your parenting style creates a situation no book can perfectly address. The best advice respects that reality and gives you tools to think through decisions rather than telling you exactly what to do.

Remember: you're literally evolved for this parenting thing. Trust yourself, stay curious, and don't be afraid to sample widely while committing selectively.

---

Related Posts:

• Back to: The Secret to Understanding Your Child's Mind
• The Power of Asking Questions Back
• Why Kids Sneak Around