We've all been there. Your child approaches with that familiar look of curiosity and asks a question. Your parenting instincts kick in, and you immediately launch into explanation mode.
But what if jumping straight to answers is actually missing the point entirely?
After years of countless conversations with my kids, I've discovered something that completely changed how I handle their questions: the power of asking questions back.
The Hidden Problem with Children's Questions
Here's what most parents don't realize: when children ask you questions, they're often not asking what you think they're asking.
Children use the same words and sentences we do, but they can have totally different meanings behind them. What sounds like bedtime curiosity might actually be anxiety. What sounds like geography questions might be confusion about something completely different.
This disconnect happens because children are constantly trying to make sense of a confusing world, and sometimes their questions come from misconceptions we can't see on the surface.
Why Your "Correct" Answer Might Be Wrong
Even when you give a perfectly accurate, age-appropriate answer, it can be completely misunderstood if your child was operating from a different framework.
Example: If your child asks "Where did I come from?" and you launch into reproduction, but they were asking about geography—what city or hospital they were born in—your technically correct answer doesn't address their actual question at all.
This is why asking questions back isn't just helpful—it's essential.
The Three-Step Question-Back Method
When your child asks you a question, resist the urge to answer immediately. Follow this process:
Step 1: Understand What They're Really Asking
Before you can give any answer, understand what they actually want to know:
- "What made you think about that?"
- "Tell me more about what you're wondering"
- "What do you already know about this?"
This doesn't just happen with children—it happens anytime someone is working with limited vocabulary or different language frameworks. I remember when a migrant worker caring for my mother-in-law asked what sounded like "How much do you cost?" Instead of jumping to conclusions, I asked questions to figure out what she meant. Eventually she said, "I cost 36. How much do you cost?" I realized she was asking about age but didn't have the right English words yet.
This same thing happens with children constantly, even when they're speaking the same language as us.
Step 2: Uncover Their Basic Assumptions
Children often ask questions based on misconceptions or incomplete information. If you answer without understanding their starting point, your answer will be interpreted through their existing (possibly incorrect) framework.
Dig deeper:
- "What do you think might happen?"
- "Where did you hear about this?"
- "What do you think the answer might be?"
Step 3: Let Them Experience Their Own Thinking
Instead of giving ready-made answers, asking questions back allows children to:
- Process their own thoughts
- Develop critical thinking skills
- Feel heard and understood
- Build confidence in problem-solving
Real-Life Examples
The Geography vs. Biology Mix-Up
Instead of immediately answering "Where did I come from?" you might ask:
- "What made you curious about that?"
- "What do you want to know about where you came from?"
- "Did someone say something that made you wonder?"
You might discover they're asking about what hospital they were born in, or why you moved from one place to another.
The Kindergarten Love Language
When my second son was in kindergarten, he developed his own vocabulary around affection. In his world, "I fell in love" meant they kissed, "I got married" meant they hugged, and "I kissed a girl" meant something even more innocent.
He'd come home saying, "Today I married Lilu and fell in love with Leah," and my mother-in-law nearly had a stroke. Instead of panicking, I kissed my husband on the cheek, turned to my son and asked, "What did Mom and Dad just do?" He immediately said, "Oh, you fell in love!"
One simple question revealed his entire vocabulary was different from what we assumed. What sounded alarming was actually perfectly innocent.
An Unexpected Benefit: It Reduces Your Stress
Here's something I didn't expect: asking questions back actually makes parenting less stressful.
We were walking home one drizzly evening when my older son looked up and said, "The sky looks weird tonight." To my problem-solving brain, this sounded like a problem. The only issue? There was absolutely nothing I could do about it.
I became genuinely upset. Here was my son presenting me with an impossible task—fixing the sky.
A smarter approach would have been to ask: "What do you mean by that?" or "What seems odd about it to you?" Just one question to understand his perspective instead of jumping to problem-solving mode.
The Depressed Poet Misconception
My son went through a poem-writing phase in elementary school. I shared his poems with my mother, who shared them with my aunt. One day my mother came back worried: "Your son is depressed. Did you read his last poem? My sister and I think it shows real distress."
Instead of panicking, I went to my son and asked, "Tell me about this poem." He explained he was experimenting with writing from different perspectives—wondering what it would be like to be in various emotional situations. Then he went right back to playing computer games with his friends.
When we assume we know what someone means without asking, we often create stress and problems that don't actually exist.
The Long-Term Benefits
Beyond reducing stress, this approach teaches children that their thoughts and perspectives matter. They learn that conversation is two-way, and that thinking through problems together is more valuable than getting quick answers.
Over time, you'll notice:
- They become more comfortable sharing what's really on their mind
- Problem-solving becomes collaborative
- They develop stronger critical thinking skills
- Your relationship deepens because they feel truly heard
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake #1: Asking leading questions
Instead of "Are you worried about something?" try "What's going through your mind about this?"
Mistake #2: Getting impatient with the process
Remember: the conversation is often more important than the answer.
Mistake #3: Still giving the lecture afterward
Once you understand what they're really asking, keep your actual answer focused and relevant to their real concern.
When to Use This Method (And When Not To)
Use question-back approach for:
- Curious questions about how the world works
- Questions that seem to come out of nowhere
- Repeated questions about the same topic
- Questions about sensitive or complex topics
Give direct answers for:
- Safety-related urgent situations
- Simple factual questions ("What time is dinner?")
- When your child is clearly distressed and needs immediate reassurance
Start Small
You don't need to transform every question into deep philosophical discussion. Start with one question back before you give your answer. Even that small change will shift how your child approaches conversations with you.
The bottom line: You're not just answering their question. You're teaching them how to think.
Related Posts:
- Back to: The Secret to Understanding Your Child's Mind
- Understanding Toddler "Yes" Responses
- Next: Filtering Parenting Advice
No comments:
Post a Comment