Picture this: You're at a family gathering. Your sister approaches with her 2-year-old—you haven't seen them in 6 months. You crouch down and ask the child, "Do you know who I am?"
"Yes!" comes the confident reply.
Your heart melts. Then you start chatting, asking questions, and it becomes painfully obvious this child has zero idea who you are.
If you've felt that mix of confusion and mild frustration when a toddler confidently answers "yes" to something they clearly don't understand or know, here's what's actually happening—and how to work with it instead of against it.
They're Answering a Different Question
When a toddler says "yes," they're often answering a completely different question than the one they were asked.
You asked: "Do you know who I am?"
They heard: "Do you want me to tell you who I am?"
And to that question, "yes" is absolutely the right answer. They're saying, "Yes, I want to know!"
This isn't confusion—it's sophisticated communication. They understand that questions lead to information, and they want that information.
"Yes" Is the Smart Social Answer
For toddlers, "yes" also carries emotional intelligence:
- It keeps conversations going
- It makes adults happy
- It feels socially correct
- It's the safe choice when uncertain
From their perspective, "yes" opens doors while "no" might shut them down.
Why Adults Get Frustrated (And Why We Shouldn't)
We're Testing Instead of Connecting
When we ask "Do you know who I am?" we're essentially giving a pop quiz. But toddlers aren't hearing a test—they're hearing an invitation to learn something new.
The frustration comes from mismatched expectations:
- Adult expectation: They should recognize me and give accurate information
- Toddler reality: They want to engage and learn, regardless of current knowledge
These Situations Stress Kids Out
Here's the toddler's experience: They gave what felt like the perfect answer ("Yes, tell me!"), but suddenly the adult seems upset and instead of more information , they are given the 3rd degree.
Is it any wonder kids don't understand why their enthusiastic response has created tension?
How to Work With This Reality
Skip the Quiz, Start with Connection
Replace: "Do you know who I am?"
With: "Hi! I'm Uncle Mike, your daddy's brother. I haven't seen you in so long!"
Replace: "Do you remember what we did yesterday?"
With: "Yesterday we went to the park and you loved the swings. Want to tell me about your favorite part?"
When You Need Actual Information
If you genuinely need to know what your toddler knows, ask specific questions:
- "What's my name?" instead of "Do you know my name?"
- "Show me the red block" instead of "Do you know which one is red?"
- "Tell me about the dog we saw" instead of "Do you remember the dog?"
Recognize Their Communication Style
When a toddler keeps saying "yes" to everything, they're often communicating:
- "I want to keep talking with you"
- "I want to learn more"
- "I like this interaction"
- "Please tell me the answer"
What This Reveals About Development
This "yes" response shows toddlers understand complex concepts:
- Questions usually lead to interesting information
- Positive responses keep interactions going
- Adults appreciate engagement
- Communication is about connection, not just facts
Your toddler's enthusiastic "yes" to questions they can't answer demonstrates they're mastering the social aspects of communication—arguably the most important part.
Key Takeaways for Stress-Free Interactions
Understanding this dynamic transforms your expectations:
- Their "yes" often means "tell me more"
- Skip the testing—lead with information
- This shows intelligence, not confusion
- Focus on connection over correctness
- The stress is unnecessary for everyone
The next time a toddler confidently says "yes" to something they clearly don't understand, remember: they might just be saying, "Yes, I'd love to know!"
And honestly? That's a pretty wonderful response to life.
Related Posts: